Letters of
Support
March 10, 2021
New York State Department of Corrections and Community Supervision Executive Clemency Bureau The Harriman State Campus, Building 2 1220 Washington Avenue Albany, New York 12226-2050 Att: Clemency Board
RE: Kassan Messiah, DIN#95A6899 Dear Sir or Madam: This letter is written in support of Mr. Kassan Messiah's Petition for Clemency.
I am a retired attorney, admitted to the bar in New York. I'm familiar with Mr. Messiah's case through my husband's work as a Private Investigator, and my personal contact with his wife, Lorraine.
My husband, Edwin P. Webster, (now deceased) was heavily involved in Mr. Messiah's case, from 2016 through 2018.
Ed had been an investigator for more than 40 years, handling a broad range of cases including million-dollar insurance fraud and murder-for profit His guiding principle in each instance was to follow the evidence wherever it would lead, even if the results were unfavorable to his client He always made it clear that he would not alter or write his final report to favor one outcome over another. My husband was a man of unfaltering integrity.
At some point during his investigations, Ed became unequivocally convinced that Kassan was innocent based on the facts, and on evidence he compiled.
I followed Kassan's case from the beginning, as well. Ed often discussed his findings with me, to get my perspective as a neutral party. When we discussed his work on other cases, I often sided with the prosecution's assertions, not the defense. However, in this instance, I found Ed's analysis and conclusions compelling. I agreed with his assessment that Kassan was innocent of the crimes charged, and that there were Constitutional irregularities regarding his line-up and preemptory challenges at Voir Dire.
More importantly, Kassan has used his time in prison in a positive way. Throughout his incarceration he's been on the Liaison Committee and was voted Chairman four times and Co-Chair two times; he started a boxing program at Greenhaven Correctional and trained inmates at that facility; and although there is no official boxing program at Sing Sing, he continues to train and mentor inmates. Many of these men who were subsequently released are successful, and they keep in touch with Kassan and his family.
In addition, he completed various programs offered by DOCCS, he participates in Family Programming offered by the Osborne Association, and he is only 12 credits away from receiving his bachelor's degree, all of which demonstrate his desire to be a productive citizen and positive influence in the community.
My ongoing conversations with members of Kassan's family have convinced me there is a loving and involved group of individuals committed to supporting him if he were granted a release from incarceration.
Based on the substantial time already served by Mr. Messiah, the questionable circumstances surrounding the original case, and his positive contributions while in prison, I respectfully submit this letter in support of the petition and hope the Board will consider clemency.
Sincerely,
Diane Webster, Esq.
Re: Letter of Clemency Support Kassan Messiah #95A6899
To whom it May Concern:
My name is Imani Supreme Messiah, I'm 29 years of age and the oldest daughter of Kassan Supreme Messiah Sr. (95A6899). I became a mother in my teens to two black boys who are presently at the tender ages of 12 and 10. I graduated valedictorian of my junior high school and later earned a college scholarship attending Montclair State University. As a state licensed massage therapist employed by the New York Giants Organization and a (private firm) for more than six years, I've become a successful citizen and I thank my parents for that. Currently I'm looking for a location to begin my own franchise and I specifically thank my father for his unwavering optimism. The success of my siblings and I are a direct product of his impact and guiding hands. I know other people can be successful in life if my father was given the opportunity to help them.
I included my father's Din Number because that's all I've ever known to be his identifier in what I was told was a camp, that I soon realized was a prison. I was two years old when I began visiting my father. I can remember the excitement I had when I finally memorized my Dad's identification number but simultaneously naive in understanding it was that number that would keep him away from me. My mother would tell my brother and I that Dad was at a camp and had to stay for a while. Our weekly visits were so routine that at such a young age, we believed he was at a camp for Dad's. I can remember being seated waiting for my father to arrive in the visiting room and the moment we saw his face at the door, coming down the ramp or walking into the room, my brother and I would scurry from our chairs and run and jump in his arms. The pure love and joy I felt was incredible.
I distinctly remember at Greenhaven Correctional Facility, there was a yard in the visitation area and I remember playing in that yard with my father. He would throw us in the air, swing us around, chase us and always created games for us to play. My Dad was the center of attention with every child in the yard as they began lining up for their turn to be tossed in the air and he did. When my Dad played games with us he was very competitive, if we won we earned it. However, play time came only after we completed whatever our assignments were that my Dad had planned for that visit. I learned to tell time by the age of four and I was doing multiplication in the first grade. I was always ahead of my class, as were my siblings. I looked forward to our family visits at what we thought was my Dad's house because we knew we would wake up and Dad would be there and his physical presence meant everything. I felt like my family was whole, we were happy and it felt safe.
My fathers love and guiding hands have carried over with my children Aman and Ayan Messiah-Clanton. Seeing them run to my Dad the way I did as a child melts my heart but not only because of the love they share but because my father has been incarcerated for so long. I'm not completely sure when I came to the realization that my father was legitimately in prison and not coming home but | will never forget the feelings | had and still do today. It feels like my family and | are incomplete and have been for so long.
Since I was a child, | have been given time frames and prospective dates of release and would get my hopes up but after appeal denials and plenty of disappointments, | learned to accept the reality of the battle we faced. However, | have not accepted defeat in obtaining justice for my Dad nor has my family. My Dad has missed so much not being home with his family; graduations, celebrations, father/daughter dances, sporting events etc. but aside from my family, the world has missed the contributions of a great man. The exemplary example set by my father has shaped me into a faithful, hardworking, intelligent leader and it's because of his strength, lessons, and no excuses attitude. The nurturing and loving guidance my Dad provides even today has elevated my confidence to be successful in life.
There is a need for guidance in communities of color, where in many broken homes, the father figure is the missing element. The lack of having a male role model in many cases have lead our young men to seek that relationship in the streets, my Dad was one of those young men. We must do everything we can to break the cycle of incarceration. The wealth of knowledge and support that my Dad can provide our youth that look like his grandsons would be outstanding if he were free.
My father has been that guiding force for his children, extended family members and other men as well. I've always seen the reverence that my Dad received from high ranking officers as well as other men who were incarcerated and | remain amazed. However, as an adult | now understand that the respect he receives is because he's a good man. My father exemplifies great character and | too respect him because of it, especially because he remains humble.
My Dad has proven to be successful in the many roles he has; father, husband, teacher, therapist and trainer. He accomplished these roles within the confines of a correctional facility. Imagine the impact my Dad could have if he were released and freely mentoring youth from the outside. After all, my siblings and | were his first success stories and now the countless individuals he's encountered during his incarceration.
It's for all the reasons stated that I'm pleading that the Board will approve the application presented by my father, Kassan S. Messiah, Sr. granting him clemency, thank you.
Sincerely,
Imani S. Messiah
To whom it may concern,
My name is Lamarr Little, DIN #01A2318 and part of my rehabilitation was inspired or influenced by Kassan Messiah.During the early stage of my incarceration, I met Kassan while in Green Haven correctional facility. There he was apart of the boxing program; and I thought he was an excellent fighter, he was also an excellent mentor. He prepared me for the greatest fight of my life: the fight within myself.
At the time I was relatively young, angry, and did not know what to do with a twenty-five-to-life sentence. However, Kassan saw something in me that I did not see in myself. By taking time out to encourage me changed how I felt about myself, and my circumstances. He inspired me to not give up and to strengthen my family ties. In addition, he encouraged me to do something with my talents, educate myself, how to organize and be inclusive, and most importantly, how to maintain my sanity in a prison environment. Due to unforeseen circumstances, Kassan was transferred, but he had made a lasting impression. He transferred to Eastern Correctional facility, and not only was I happy to see him. I was happy to share my growth and accomplishments with him.
I recently received my Bachelor's Degree in Social Studies with BardCollege (BPI). I am a Pen American Award winning writer, and my artwork and poetry have been published in several magazines, books, and newspapers. He and I talked about mentorship, transformative power, being good husbands, and how we can still make an impact in the world, and in the lives of the misguided youth.
I was 24 when I met Kassan, and I understand the importance of mentorship because of him. His mentorship transformed me. And, that's something about Kassan Messiah that you might not know. I am in full support of his release because I know that he will be impactful in society.
Sincerely, Lamarr Little
May 18, 2021
To Whom It May Concern,
When we consider the people whom we'd prefer to be surrounded by; we think of kindness and reliability. Respect! We yern for not only someone with a 'can do' spirit but a 'you can do it' spirit. Unconditional Support is what our society is missing and has unconsciously transformed us into a 'CANCEL CULTURE'. How do we assure our children of our undying love and support? We lead by example!
I am a product of my environment! I was born to a single mother of 2, battling a drug addiction and an absentee father. Since before I could remember Lorraine and Kassan Messiah has always been a thriving part of my existence. From making sure I was safe, to feed and even clothed at times. It wasn't until I was 11, that they became caregivers to my sister and I. Kassan and Lorraine Messiah were already parents of 3! Being already in unimaginable circumstances, they didn't hesitate to step up. Not only was I more than a task, being engulfed in misfortunes, I was an angry kid. They never gave up on me! They gave me what Kassan Sr. had deserved and I had already proven that I may not have deserved it. I was given a sense of normalcy, stability, and a home.
I was shown a kindness that many may never experience! See when the world gives up on you because your parents already have then what?! It Isn't us who have FAILED YOU! We preach forgiveness, repentance and rehabilitation, yet it was the actions of the words that I was offered. Most of us don't have the ability to offer the same kindness we are in need of. The kindness, empathy and respect that I carry myself with today is the gift I was given at no price.
I believe he deserves clemency.
Respectfully,
Naomi Bennett-Collins